When can an attorney reject a court appointment?

An attorney can reject a court appointment when they lack the competence to handle the case. Competence is a foundational ethical obligation for lawyers, as outlined in professional conduct rules. Attorneys must ensure that they are qualified to represent a client adequately in any given matter, and this includes possessing the necessary legal knowledge and skills relevant to the case at hand. If they believe they do not have the required expertise or experience to provide competent representation, they have a professional responsibility to decline the appointment to protect the interests of the client and uphold the integrity of the legal profession.

In contrast, feeling overwhelmed by a current caseload does not typically justify rejecting an appointment. Similarly, having social obligations is not a valid reason under professional ethics to decline a court appointment. Lastly, the inability to charge a premium fee does not relate to an attorney's competence or ethical responsibility in accepting cases and therefore does not justify rejecting an appointment.